Page 287
REVISTA IEEE 9
http://revista.ieee.es/index.php/ieee
289
Manuel García Ruiz The cartoon, the new weapon of the First World
straightforward and simple medium, accessible to all social classes irrespective of their
cultural background.
Picking up once more on the question I put to the reader at the start, are we able
to speak of cartoons of an ideological nature produced during the First World War?
Categorically, yes. The pamphlets, posters, cartoons, comics etc. published during
the conflict were undeniably ideologically charged and found a relatively broad and
receptive audience. To a lesser degree, the revisionist works that saw the light of day
after the war (most of these in recent years) contain a dominant desire to awaken
feelings of rejection or blame in times long after the event.
For many years, the Great War had been relegated to an overlooked part of our history,
partly as it was overshadowed by the attractive part that followed, which was to be more
universal and which, in particular, grew to mythic proportions in cinema. Yet, it has also
been confined to a corner of our memory due to its rawness, because of the horror that
it awakens in our conscience. No explanation could be found as to the moral regress
endured following a period in time in which humankind seemed to prosper in leaps and
bounds. There has been an abundance of studies, treatises, books and also comics that
have appeared around the centenary of the war to jolt us into remembrance.
Within a few years, our memory will tend to forget once more and the gap left
by the Great War will be filled until a new event awakens us with another dramatic
development to shake our conscience.
What could be of greater interest would be how governments might act given a
repeat of a situation like that experienced a century ago. Today’s society demands
instantaneous real-time information, hence media such as the internet and its social
networks, or television, have triumphed. Even conventional media, such as the press,
have been forced to adapt so as not to lose this battle. And governments, or any group
seeking notoriety, do not think twice before making use of these media available to
them. It is worth considering whether the most obsolete, such as those that we have
analysed here (comic strips, cartoons, posters etc.) could find their place in a future
crisis. The most rational logic would invite us to answer no, yet why pass up such
a simple and cheap tool that -certainly in today’s world- has achieved widespread
dissemination? One only has to recall the uproar and consequences unleashed by the
publication of several drawings of Mohammed in Norwegian and Danish weekly papers
in 2006. Or how the PSYOPS section (Psychological Operations, part of Information
Operations) of the US Department of Defense widely uses similar means, especially
in countries which currently have lower levels of education.
This is why the cartoon and other similar publications will not fall into disuse if a
new conflict or serious crisis situation is to break out, especially as a supplementary
resource. All of this without accounting for the potential that they offer in the present
day for shaping patriotic or nationalist ideologies. Owen Griffiths provides an example
of this in his work Militarizing Japan: Patriotism, Profit and Children’s Print Media, or
current comics that seek the support of the public, usually a young audience, in order
to create a climate of animosity against a rival country.
- The Fifth Element
- Book review
- En busca de una Estrategia de Seguridad Nacional
- Ángel Gómez de Ágreda
- Book review
- Ethical leadership and responsible management as levers for improvement in security, emergency and defence organisations
- Javier Jordán Enamorado
- Central Asians fighting in Syria: the danger of Islamic State retournees to Central Asia
- Carlos García-Guiu López
- The Islamic state and Jabhat Al-Nusra; new actors in Lebanon?
- Antonio Alonso Marcos
- The cartoon, the new weapon of the first world war
- Javier Lion Bustillo
- Defining a model for analysis of civil-military relations patterns
- Manuel García Ruiz
- Proxy wars in cyberspace
- Salvador Sánchez Tapia
- Presentation of Issue nº 9 of the Spanish Institute for Strategic Studies (IEEE) Magazine
- Manuel R. Torres Soriano
- Miguel Ángel Ballesteros Martín
- Consejo de redacción
- Miguel Ángel Ballesteros Martín
- Presentación de la revista
- Manuel R. Torres Soriano
- Guerras por delegación en el ciberespacio
- Proxy wars in cyberspace
- Salvador SánchezTapia
- Definición de un procedimiento de análisis de modelos de relaciones cívico-militares
- Defining a model for analysis of civil-military relations patterns
- Manuel García Ruiz
- La viñeta, la nueva arma durante la I Guerra Mundial
- The cartoon, the new weapon of the First World War
- Javier Lion Bustillo
- El Estado Islámico y Jabhat al-Nusra, ¿nuevos actores en el Líbano?
- The Islamic State and Jabhat Al-Nusra; new actors in Lebanon?
- Antonio Alonso Marcos
- Centroasiáticos luchando en Siria: El peligro de los retornados del Estado Islámico para Asia Central
- Central Asians fighting in Syria: The danger of Islamic State retournees to Central Asia
- Carlos García-Guiu López
- Liderazgo ético y gestión responsable como vectores de mejora en las Organizaciones de Seguridad, Emergencia y Defensa
- Ethical leadership and responsible management as levers for improvement in security, emergency and defence organisations
- Javier Jordán Enamorado
- En busca de una Estrategia de Seguridad Nacional
- Ángel Gómez de Ágreda
- El quinto elemento
- Normas para los autores de artículos
- p 111-131.pdf
- The Fifth Element
- Book review
- En busca de una Estrategia de Seguridad Nacional
- Ángel Gómez de Ágreda
- Book review
- Ethical leadership and responsible management as levers for improvement in security, emergency and defence organisations
- Javier Jordán Enamorado
- Central Asians fighting in Syria: the danger of Islamic State retournees to Central Asia
- Carlos García-Guiu López
- The Islamic state and Jabhat Al-Nusra; new actors in Lebanon?
- Antonio Alonso Marcos
- The cartoon, the new weapon of the first world war
- Javier Lion Bustillo
- Defining a model for analysis of civil-military relations patterns
- Manuel García Ruiz
- Proxy wars in cyberspace
- Salvador Sánchez Tapia
- Presentation of Issue nº 9 of the Spanish Institute for Strategic Studies (IEEE) Magazine
- Manuel R. Torres Soriano
- Miguel Ángel Ballesteros Martín
- Consejo de redacción
- Miguel Ángel Ballesteros Martín
- Presentación de la revista
- Manuel R. Torres Soriano
- Guerras por delegación en el ciberespacio
- Proxy wars in cyberspace
- Salvador SánchezTapia
- Definición de un procedimiento de análisis de modelos de relaciones cívico-militares
- Defining a model for analysis of civil-military relations patterns
- Manuel García Ruiz
- La viñeta, la nueva arma durante la I Guerra Mundial
- The cartoon, the new weapon of the First World War
- Javier Lion Bustillo
- El Estado Islámico y Jabhat al-Nusra, ¿nuevos actores en el Líbano?
- The Islamic State and Jabhat Al-Nusra; new actors in Lebanon?
- Antonio Alonso Marcos
- Centroasiáticos luchando en Siria: El peligro de los retornados del Estado Islámico para Asia Central
- Central Asians fighting in Syria: The danger of Islamic State retournees to Central Asia
- Carlos García-Guiu López
- Liderazgo ético y gestión responsable como vectores de mejora en las Organizaciones de Seguridad, Emergencia y Defensa
- Ethical leadership and responsible management as levers for improvement in security, emergency and defence organisations
- Javier Jordán Enamorado
- En busca de una Estrategia de Seguridad Nacional
- Ángel Gómez de Ágreda
- El quinto elemento
- Normas para los autores de artículos
REVISTA IEEE 9
To see the actual publication please follow the link above